Movies Like Mystery Island: Play for Keeps

Ranked by shared directors, cast, themes, genre, and era — not just generic recommendations.

Mystery Island: Winner Takes All

2025·1h 24m·★ 5.8·Steven R. Monroe

Mystery Island Collection3 shared cast incl. Elizabeth Henstridge & Charlie WeberDir. Steven R. Monroe

Mystery Island

2023·1h 24m·★ 5.7·Nicholas Humphries

Mystery Island Collection3 shared cast incl. Elizabeth Henstridge & Charlie WeberTV Movie & Mystery

Crossword Mysteries: Abracadaver

2020·1h 25m·★ 6.9·Jonathan Wright

Fans also likedTV Movie & Mystery

Mystery 101: Playing Dead

2019·1h 24m·★ 7.0·Blair Hayes

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

Mystery 101: Dead Talk

2019·1h 24m·★ 7.2·Winnifred Jong

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

Crossword Mysteries: Proposing Murder

2019·1h 22m·★ 6.9·Don McCutcheon

Fans also likedTV Movie & Mystery

Mystery 101

2019·1h 24m·★ 7.1·Blair Hayes

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

A Beautiful Place to Die: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery

2020·1h 25m·★ 6.7·Mark Jean

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

Miss Marple: 4.50 from Paddington

1987·1h 50m·★ 7.6·Martyn Friend

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

Last Scene Alive: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

2018·1h 25m·★ 6.8·Martin Wood

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

Hailey Dean Mysteries: Deadly Estate

2017·1h 30m·★ 6.7·Terry Ingram

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

Hailey Dean Mysteries: Dating Is Murder

2017·1h 24m·★ 6.8·Michael Robison

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

Crossword Mysteries: A Puzzle to Die For

2019·1h 24m·★ 6.5·Don McCutcheon

Fans also likedTV Movie & Mystery

Murder, She Baked: Just Desserts

2017·1h 24m·★ 6.8·Kristoffer Tabori

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

A Bone to Pick: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

2015·1h 23m·★ 6.6·Martin Wood

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

The Count of Monte-Cristo

1975·1h 59m·★ 6.9·David Greene

Fans also likedAdventure & TV Movie

Garage Sale Mystery: A Case Of Murder

2017·1h 24m·★ 7.0·Neill Fearnley

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

Framed for Murder: A Fixer Upper Mystery

2017·1h 23m·★ 6.7·Mark Jean

Fans also likedTV Movie & Mystery

Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent

2016·1h 24m·★ 6.9·Peter DeLuise

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

Miss Marple: The Murder at the Vicarage

1986·1h 42m·★ 7.5·Julian Amyes

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie

How Good Is Mystery Island: Play for Keeps?

Ratings across IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB, plus our verdict.

Where to Watch Mystery Island: Play for Keeps

Streaming, rental, and purchase options across 40+ countries.

CountryUnited States

Type

AllStreamRentBuyTheaters

United States

US

Stream

6

fuboTV

YouTube TV

Philo

Hallmark+ Amazon Channel

Hallmark+ Apple TV Channel

Hallmark TV Amazon Channel

Available in 3 countries