Movies Like Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent

Ranked by shared directors, cast, themes, genre, and era — not just generic recommendations.

Garage Sale Mystery: The Deadly Room

2015·1h 24m·★ 6.9·Peter DeLuise

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection4 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah Strange2 shared crew

Garage Sale Mystery: The Wedding Dress

2015·1h 23m·★ 6.9·Peter DeLuise

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection4 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeDir. Peter DeLuise

Garage Sale Mystery: All That Glitters

2014·1h 23m·★ 6.9·Peter DeLuise

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection4 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Steve BacicDir. Peter DeLuise

Garage Sale Mystery: A Case Of Murder

2017·1h 24m·★ 7.0·Neill Fearnley

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection6 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeFans also liked

Garage Sale Mystery

2013·2h·★ 7.0·Peter DeLuise

Garage Sale Mysteries CollectionBoth star Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeDir. Peter DeLuise

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Pandora's Box Murders

2018·1h 24m·★ 7.0·Neill Fearnley

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection6 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeDrama & Mystery & TV Movie

Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder In D Minor

2018·1h 24m·★ 7.0·Neill Fearnley

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection5 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeMystery & TV Movie & Drama

Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval

2017·1h 24m·★ 6.9·Neill Fearnley

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection5 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeMystery & TV Movie & Drama

Garage Sale Mystery: Murder By Text

2017·1h 23m·★ 6.8·Neill Fearnley

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection5 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeTV Movie & Mystery & Drama

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Mask Murder

2018·1h 24m·★ 6.9·Mel Damski

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection5 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Steve BacicMystery & TV Movie

Garage Sale Mysteries: Searched & Seized

2021·1h 24m·★ 6.9·Neill Fearnley

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection4 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeTV Movie & Mystery

Garage Sale Mystery: The Art of Murder

2017·1h 23m·★ 6.7·Kristoffer Tabori

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection5 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Steve BacicTV Movie & Mystery

Garage Sale Mystery: The Novel Murders

2016·1h 24m·★ 7.0·Norma Bailey

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection4 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeTV Movie & Mystery

Garage Sale Mystery: The Beach Murder

2017·1h 24m·★ 6.8·Neill Fearnley

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection5 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeMystery & TV Movie

Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder

2018·1h 24m·★ 7.0·Neill Fearnley

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection6 shared cast incl. Lori Loughlin & Sarah StrangeMystery & TV Movie

Murder, She Baked: A Plum Pudding Mystery

2015·1h 24m·★ 6.8·Kristoffer Tabori

Fans also likedTV Movie & Mystery & DramaStarring Johannah Newmarch

A Beautiful Place to Die: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery

2020·1h 25m·★ 6.7·Mark Jean

Fans also likedMystery & Drama & TV Movie

Last Scene Alive: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

2018·1h 25m·★ 6.8·Martin Wood

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie & Drama

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reunited and It Feels So Deadly

2020·1h 24m·★ 6.9·Martin Wood

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie & Drama

Dead Over Heels: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

2017·1h 24m·★ 6.8·Terry Ingram

Fans also likedMystery & TV Movie & Drama

How Good Is Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent?

Ratings across IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB, plus our verdict.