

Shows Like Black Butler
In Victorian London, 12-year-old business magnate Ciel Phantomhive thwarts dangers to the queen as he's watched over by his demon butler, Sebastian.
Ranked by shared creators, cast, themes, genre, and network — not just generic recommendations.

Blue Exorcist
Boy bonded with a demon protector battles supernatural threats; same shounen dark-fantasy/demon-pact core as Black Butler.

The Mystic Archives of Dantalian
Victorian-era English setting, supernatural mysteries, gothic tone, demonic pact between aristocrat and otherworldly girl; shares Daisuke Ono.

JUJUTSU KAISEN
Shounen dark fantasy with exorcism, curses and a human host bound to a demon — same demon-pact dynamic as Ciel and Sebastian.

Akuma Kun
Boy raised by a demon partners with a Mephisto figure to investigate paranormal mysteries; near-direct Black Butler analogue.

Welcome to Demon School! Iruma-kun
Young human bonded to a demon family in a gothic-flavored setting; lighter tone but same demon-companion premise, also stars Daisuke Ono.

Hell Girl
Dark supernatural revenge anthology where humans bargain with an otherworldly being — same Faustian-pact theme as Sebastian's contract.

Claymore
Dark fantasy with demon hunters and human/demon hybrids; shares the brooding gothic-action tone fans of Black Butler enjoy.

Berserk
Gothic dark fantasy of revenge, demons and damnation — tonal sibling to Black Butler's grim contract narrative.

Seraph of the End
Young protagonist with tragic past wields supernatural power against monstrous threats in a dark-fantasy world.

Hell's Paradise
Historical (Edo) dark-fantasy survival with demonic creatures and morally complex protectors — similar gothic-action vibe.

Devils' Line
Half-demon protagonist working a supernatural task force; shares the demon-among-humans dynamic.

Twin Star Exorcists
Exorcists battling demons in a shounen action-supernatural framework with personal pacts and rivalries.

Ushio and Tora
Boy bound to a demon partner — direct echo of the Ciel/Sebastian dynamic in a shounen-action setting.

The Apothecary Diaries
Historical court mysteries solved by a clever underling serving nobility — mirrors Ciel's investigative role for the Crown.

Umineko: When They Cry
Gothic mystery with witches, demons and detective logic in an aristocratic setting; also shares Daisuke Ono.

91 Days
Period-piece (1920s) revenge tale with a coldly composed protagonist orchestrating retribution — thematic match for Ciel.

Rin: Daughters of Mnemosyne
Supernatural detective with immortal/dark elements; shares the noir-investigation-with-monsters template.

Agatha Christie's Poirot
Period-British detective drama matches Black Butler's Victorian-mystery side, minus the supernatural.

Supernatural
Long-running demon-hunting drama; appeals to viewers drawn to Black Butler's demon and occult elements.

Junji Ito Collection
Anthology of dark, gothic-horror tales for fans of Black Butler's macabre side episodes.
How Good Is Black Butler?
Ratings across IMDb and TMDB, plus our verdict.
Where to Watch Black Butler
Streaming, rental, and purchase options across 40+ countries.
United States
USStream
4Buy
3Available in 80 countries