Movies Like The Guilty

Ranked by shared directors, cast, themes, genre, and era — not just generic recommendations.

High Tide

1947·1h 12m·★ 6.5·John Reinhardt

2 shared crewBoth star Don Castle & Regis ToomeyDir. John Reinhardt

Nancy Drew... Reporter

1939·1h 8m·★ 6.5·William Clemens

3 shared cast incl. Bonita Granville & John LitelCrime & Mystery

She's the Man

2006·1h 45m·★ 6.4·Andy Fickman

Themes: twin sister, mistaken identity

Murder She Said

1961·1h 27m·★ 7.3·George Pollock

TMDB recommendsCrime & Mystery

Eastern Promises

2007·1h 40m·★ 7.6·David Cronenberg

TMDB recommendsCrime & Mystery

Murder, My Sweet

1944·1h 35m·★ 7.5·Edward Dmytryk

TMDB recommendsCrime & Mystery

Murder at the Gallop

1963·1h 21m·★ 7.2·George Pollock

TMDB recommendsCrime & Mystery

Murder Most Foul

1964·1h 30m·★ 7.1·George Pollock

TMDB recommendsCrime & Mystery

Murder Ahoy

1964·1h 33m·★ 7.0·George Pollock

TMDB recommendsCrime & Mystery

Nancy Drew and the Hidden Staircase

1939·1h·★ 6.6·William Clemens

Both star Bonita Granville & John LitelCrime & Mystery

Lady in the Lake

1946·1h 45m·★ 6.5·Robert Montgomery

TMDB recommendsMystery & Crime

The Brasher Doubloon

1947·1h 12m·★ 6.6·John Brahm

TMDB recommendsMystery & Crime

Rebecca

1940·2h 10m·★ 8.0·Alfred Hitchcock

TMDB recommends

Out of the Past

1947·1h 37m·★ 7.9·Jacques Tourneur

TMDB recommends

The Killing

1956·1h 25m·★ 7.9·Stanley Kubrick

TMDB recommends

Laura

1944·1h 28m·★ 7.9·Otto Preminger

TMDB recommends

Mystery 101

2019·1h 24m·★ 7.1·Blair Hayes

Fans also likedCrime & Mystery

The 39 Steps

1935·1h 26m·★ 7.6·Alfred Hitchcock

TMDB recommends

Miss Marple: 4.50 from Paddington

1987·1h 50m·★ 7.6·Martyn Friend

Fans also likedCrime & Mystery

A History of Violence

2005·1h 36m·★ 7.4·David Cronenberg

TMDB recommends

How Good Is The Guilty?

Ratings across IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB, plus our verdict.