Similar Films
Movies Like Cropsey
2009·84 min·Dir. Joshua Zeman·★ 6.3
CrimeDocumentaryMysteryHorror
Realizing the urban legend of their youth has actually come true, two filmmakers delve into the mystery surrounding five missing children and the real-life boogeyman linked to their disappearances.
Ranked by shared directors, cast, themes, genre, and era — not just generic recommendations.
Cucuy: The Boogeyman
2018·1h 25m·★ 4.6·Peter Sullivan
Themes: boogeyman, urban legendFans also liked
The Blair Witch Project
1999·1h 21m·★ 6.5·Daniel Myrick
Themes: urban legend, found footageFans also likedHorror & Mystery
Megan Is Missing
2011·1h 26m·★ 4.6·Michael Goi
Themes: missing person, found footageFans also liked
Get Out
2017·1h 44m·★ 7.8·Jordan Peele
Themes: missing person, kidnappingMystery & Horror
Angel Heart
1987·1h 53m·★ 7.2·Alan Parker
TMDB recommendsHorror & Mystery
The Treatment
2014·2h 11m·★ 7.1·Hans Herbots
TMDB recommendsCrime & Mystery
The Ninth Gate
1999·2h 13m·★ 6.7·Roman Polanski
TMDB recommendsMystery & Horror
Killer Legends
2014·1h 26m·★ 6.2·Joshua Zeman
Documentary & Crime & HorrorStarring Joshua ZemanDir. Joshua Zeman
The Poughkeepsie Tapes
2007·1h 21m·★ 5.9·John Erick Dowdle
Fans also likedHorror & Mystery & Crime
A Working Man
2025·1h 56m·★ 5.7·David Ayer
Themes: missing person, kidnapping
The Big Lebowski
1998·1h 57m·★ 8.1·Joel Coen
TMDB recommends
Boys Don't Cry
1999·1h 58m·★ 7.5·Kimberly Peirce
TMDB recommends
The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It
2021·1h 51m·★ 6.2·Michael Chaves
Fans also likedHorror & Mystery
Water & Power: A California Heist
2017·1h 27m·★ 7.3·Marina Zenovich
TMDB recommends
Sinister
2012·1h 50m·★ 6.8·Scott Derrickson
Fans also likedHorror & Mystery
The Ring
2002·1h 55m·★ 7.1·Gore Verbinski
Fans also likedHorror & Mystery
Olympia Part Two: Festival of Beauty
1938·1h 44m·★ 7.6·Leni Riefenstahl
TMDB recommends
The Price of Gold
2014·1h 18m·★ 7.4·Nanette Burstein
TMDB recommends
Ulysse
1986·22m·★ 7.3·Agnès Varda
TMDB recommends
The Blackwell Ghost 3
2019·1h 15m·★ 6.2·Turner Clay
TMDB recommends
How Good Is Cropsey?
Ratings across IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB, plus our verdict.
Consensus
6.2Mixed Reviews
Score Breakdown
★ TMDB6.0
★ IMDb6.3
🍅 Rotten Tomatoes (Critics)N/A
◆ MetacriticN/A
The Verdict
Decent, Give It a Shot
Related Collections
Find More