Similar Shows
Shows Like Midnight Mass
2021·1 season·7 eps·Created by Mike Flanagan·Netflix·★ 7.7
MysteryDrama
The arrival of a charismatic young priest brings glorious miracles, ominous mysteries and renewed religious fervor to a dying town desperate to believe.
Ranked by shared creators, cast, themes, genre, and network — not just generic recommendations.
The Fall of the House of Usher
2023·S1 · 8 episodes·★ 7.9
5 shared cast incl. Henry Thomas & Kate SiegelCreated by Mike FlanaganBoth Miniseries
The Midnight Club
2022·S1 · 10 episodes·★ 6.5
3 shared cast incl. Igby Rigney & Annarah CymoneCreated by Mike FlanaganMystery & Drama
The Haunting of Hill House
2018·S1 · 10 episodes·★ 8.5
Created by Mike FlanaganBoth star Kate Siegel & Henry ThomasBoth Miniseries
The Haunting of Bly Manor
2020·S1 · 9 episodes·★ 7.4
Created by Mike FlanaganBoth star Henry Thomas & Rahul KohliBoth Miniseries
The Exorcist
2016·S2 · 20 episodes·★ 7.9
Fans also watchedThemes: priest, horrorMystery & Drama
Evil
2019·S4 · 50 episodes·★ 7.7
Fans also watchedThemes: priest, horrorDrama & Mystery
Grotesquerie
2024·S1 · 10 episodes·★ 6.1
Fans also watchedThemes: intense, horrorDrama & Mystery
FROM
2022·S4 · 40 episodes·★ 7.8
Themes: sheriff, priest, horrorMystery & Drama
Run Away
2026·S1 · 8 episodes·★ 6.9
Fans also watchedBoth MiniseriesDrama & Mystery
Inside Man
2022·S1 · 4 episodes·★ 6.7
Fans also watchedBoth MiniseriesDrama & Mystery
The Survivors
2025·S1 · 6 episodes·★ 6.6
Fans also watchedBoth MiniseriesDrama & Mystery
The Chosen
2019·S6 · 47 episodes·★ 9.1
Themes: miracles, religion
Banshee
2013·S4 · 38 episodes·★ 8.4
Themes: sheriff, ex-con
Dexter: New Blood
2021·S1 · 10 episodes·★ 8.0
Fans also watchedBoth Miniseries
Twin Peaks
1990·S3 · 48 episodes·★ 8.7
Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery
Broadchurch
2013·S3 · 24 episodes·★ 8.3
Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery
Jonathan Creek
1997·S5 · 26 episodes·★ 8.1
Fans also watchedMystery & Drama
Desperate Housewives
2004·S8 · 179 episodes·★ 7.6
Fans also watchedMystery & Drama
Harper's Island
2009·S1 · 13 episodes·★ 7.4
Fans also watchedMystery & Drama
Sleepy Hollow
2013·S4 · 62 episodes·★ 7.3
Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery
How Good Is Midnight Mass?
Ratings across IMDb and TMDB, plus our verdict.
Consensus
7.6Highly Rated
Score Breakdown
★ TMDB7.5
★ IMDb7.7
The Verdict
Yes, Worth Watching
Where to Watch Midnight Mass
Streaming, rental, and purchase options across 40+ countries.
United States
USStream
2
Netflix
Netflix Standard with AdsAvailable in 131 countries
Related Collections
Find More