Shows Like Big Mistakes
Blackmailed into working for some very dangerous people, two deeply incapable siblings become the most disorganized duo in organized crime.
Ranked by shared creators, cast, themes, genre, and network — not just generic recommendations.
Schitt's Creek
Created by and starring Dan Levy — same creator, same lead; closest possible franchise/creator match.
Barry
Dark comedy about an accidental criminal forced deeper into crime; tone, structure, and premise mirror Big Mistakes closely.
Fargo
Ordinary/incompetent people entangled with organized crime played as dark comedy; same tonal DNA.
The Outlaws
Disparate, incapable people forced into proximity with organized crime; Comedy/Crime with a blackmail-adjacent hook.
Snatch
Bumbling hustlers stumble into organized crime; Comedy/Crime with the same disorganized-criminals energy.
The Righteous Gemstones
Deeply incompetent siblings entangled in crime and blackmail; ensemble dark comedy with near-identical sibling dynamic.
Mr Inbetween
Dark comedy-crime hybrid about a criminal-for-hire navigating mundane life; tonal match though protagonist is competent.
Sneaky Pete
Con man hiding from gangsters under a false identity; crime-comedy with blackmail pressure and darkly funny tone.
StartUp
Reluctant civilians forced into organized crime together; lacks comedy but shares the 'dragged in unwillingly' premise.
Good Behavior
Ex-con repeatedly pulled back into crime despite best intentions; dark tone with charismatic lead perpetually in over her head.
Wild Cards
Mismatched crime-comedy duo forced into partnership; lighter tone but shares the reluctant-pair-in-crime structure.
Fleabag
Phoebe Waller-Bridge dark comedy; same auteur-comedy wave as Levy — sharp writing, self-sabotaging protagonist in chaos.
Abbott Elementary
Ensemble workplace comedy sharing Dan Levy–era warmly chaotic ensemble DNA and Rachel Sennott's broader comedy world.
A Nero Wolfe Mystery
Comedy/Crime/Mystery with eccentric detective duo; shares genre blend but entirely different era and tone.
McMafia
Reluctant civilian dragged into organized crime family; shares the outsider-in-crime-world premise without comedy.
Sons of Anarchy
Organized crime drama with deep family entanglement; shares criminal-world stakes but serious in tone, no comedy.
Mayans M.C.
SOA spin-off about organized crime and reluctant criminal identity; heavy drama, no comedic element.
Power Book IV: Force
Outsider navigating organized crime hierarchy; shares crime-world theme but no comedic or incompetent angle.
Crime Story
Organized crime saga; shares keyword only — 1986 serious police drama with no tonal match.
Hill Street Blues
Gritty urban police drama; distant cousin via crime genre only, no comedy or civilian-in-crime-world angle.
How Good Is Big Mistakes?
Ratings across IMDb and TMDB, plus our verdict.
Where to Watch Big Mistakes
Streaming, rental, and purchase options across 40+ countries.
United States
USStream
2
Netflix
Netflix Standard with AdsAvailable in 131 countries
Frequently asked about Big Mistakes
Common questions people search for, with answers written by us at MoviesPack.
How do Nicky and Morgan get pulled into organized crime?
Morgan steals a necklace from a postal store intending to bury it with their dying grandmother as a sentimental gift. This petty theft triggers a blackmail scheme that forces both siblings into a series of criminal assignments — grave robbing, drug running, and increasingly dangerous jobs — carried out for people they don't understand and can't refuse.
Who is Annette and what is her role in the crime operation?
Annette, played by Elizabeth Perkins, is Morgan's prospective mother-in-law, initially presented as an ordinary family figure. The season finale reveals she is the Italian mob boss orchestrating the entire cartel operation the siblings have been unwittingly serving. The twist is designed to recontextualize every earlier scene she appears in.
Why does Annette give the necklace back to Morgan at the end?
Returning the necklace is not a gesture of goodwill — it is a mechanism of control. By presenting it as a gift, Annette signals that she now holds authority over Morgan and the entire Dardano family. She also makes clear that Morgan must not break off the engagement to her son Max, using the necklace as a symbol of the family's permanent entanglement with the mob.
Why are Nicky and Morgan spared during the Florida confrontation?
Annette intervenes specifically to protect Morgan because Morgan is engaged to her son Max, and she does not want to jeopardize that relationship by allowing Morgan to be killed. Nicky survives as collateral of that same protection. Their survival is not earned through cunning but is entirely contingent on Annette's personal interest in keeping the engagement intact.
What tension does Nicky face as a pastor throughout the series?
Nicky is openly gay but serves a congregation that accepts gay people as individuals while officially rejecting homosexuality as a practice. As his romantic relationship with a contractor becomes more serious, he is caught between his genuine faith, his desire for acceptance from his church community, and his unwillingness to be fully honest — a personal contradiction that drives many of his worst decisions across the season.