Movies Like My Soul to Take

Ranked by shared directors, cast, themes, genre, and era — not just generic recommendations.

Psycho

1960·1h 49m·★ 8.5·Alfred Hitchcock

Themes: multiple personality disorder, mental illnessHorror & Mystery

Scream

1996·1h 52m·★ 7.4·Wes Craven

Fans also likedDir. Wes CravenHorror & Mystery

Scream 4

2011·1h 51m·★ 6.3·Wes Craven

Fans also likedDir. Wes CravenHorror & Mystery

Silent Hill

2006·2h 5m·★ 6.5·Christophe Gans

TMDB recommendsHorror & Mystery

Frankenstein

2004·1h 28m·★ 4.5·Marcus Nispel

TMDB recommendsHorror & Mystery

Donnie Darko

2001·1h 54m·★ 8.0·Richard Kelly

TMDB recommends

Dark City

1998·1h 41m·★ 7.5·Alex Proyas

TMDB recommends

Identity

2003·1h 30m·★ 7.3·James Mangold

TMDB recommends

Frenzy

1972·1h 56m·★ 7.4·Alfred Hitchcock

TMDB recommends

Fear of Rain

2021·1h 49m·★ 6.0·Castille Landon

TMDB recommends

Scream

2022·1h 54m·★ 6.3·Tyler Gillett

Fans also likedHorror & Mystery

Saw II

2005·1h 33m·★ 6.6·Darren Lynn Bousman

TMDB recommends

Goosebumps

2015·1h 43m·★ 6.3·Rob Letterman

TMDB recommends

Jaws 2

1978·1h 57m·★ 5.8·Jeannot Szwarc

TMDB recommends

I Know What You Did Last Summer

1997·1h 42m·★ 5.9·Jim Gillespie

Fans also likedHorror & Mystery

The Children

2008·1h 24m·★ 5.9·Tom Shankland

Fans also likedHorror & Mystery

Happy Birthday to Me

1981·1h 50m·★ 6.0·J. Lee Thompson

Fans also likedHorror & Mystery

The Prowler

1981·1h 29m·★ 5.9·Joseph Zito

Fans also likedHorror & Mystery

Priest of Evil

2010·1h 46m·★ 5.8·Olli Saarela

TMDB recommends

Lake Fear 2: The Swamp

2018·1h 20m·★ 3.3·Ben Wilder

TMDB recommends

How Good Is My Soul to Take?

Ratings across IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB, plus our verdict.