

Movies Like My Fault
Noah must leave her city, boyfriend, and friends to move into William Leister's mansion, the flashy and wealthy husband of her mother Rafaela. As a proud and independent 17 year old, Noah resists living in a mansion surrounded by luxury. However, it is there where she meets Nick, her new stepbrother, and the clash of their strong personalities becomes evident from the very beginning.
Ranked by shared directors, cast, themes, genre, and era — not just generic recommendations.

Our Fault
Direct sequel in the Fault trilogy; same director Domingo González, same leads Nicole Wallace & Gabriel Guevara

Your Fault
Second film in the Fault trilogy; same director and full cast, continues Noah and Nick's story

My Fault: London
English-language adaptation of the exact same source novel with identical step-sibling premise

Through My Window
Spanish YA streaming romance; forbidden love, class-divide, teen female lead — same Netflix/Amazon audience

Three Steps Above Heaven
Spanish YA novel adaptation, bad-boy rebel meets good girl, forbidden love — direct genre predecessor

Cruel Intentions
Step-sibling seduction drama with forbidden romance and enemies-to-lovers arc; same core dynamic

Twilight
YA forbidden romance adaptation, teen female protagonist, same passionate-but-dangerous love story audience

After Ever Happy
YA novel adaptation, turbulent young couple romance, same streaming platform demographic as My Fault

Endless Love
Teenage forbidden romance, disapproving parents, passionate first love — same YA romantic drama template

After
YA forbidden romance, bad-boy love interest, college setting — closest mainstream comp to My Fault audience

365 Days
European streaming forbidden romance drama; same adult-YA crossover audience who watch My Fault

After We Collided
Direct sequel in the After franchise; same passionate-enemies-to-lovers YA romance formula

Inventing the Abbotts
Brothers pursuing sisters across class lines; sibling entanglement and forbidden attraction in teen drama

Cruel Intentions 2
Step-sibling manipulation at private school; shares stepsister keyword and teen seduction premise

Charlie St. Cloud
YA-adjacent drama/romance with young male lead; sibling themes, same teen streaming demographic

The Choice
Mainstream romantic drama from YA novel; opposites-attract neighbours, same adult romance audience

Time Is Up
Teen romance drama on streaming; troubled young man meets accomplished girl — comparable YA formula

Purple Hearts
Netflix forbidden/fake romance drama; enemies-to-lovers dynamic with strong female lead, same platform audience

Lady Chatterley's Lover
Steamy forbidden romance adaptation on Netflix; class-divide passion with similar streaming audience overlap

Brideshead Revisited
Forbidden love amid wealth and family disapproval; sibling entanglement and class-driven romance, tonal cousin
How Good Is My Fault?
Ratings across IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB, plus our verdict.
Audiences rate this 7.7 points higher than critics — a crowd favorite that critics undervalued.
Where to Watch My Fault
Streaming, rental, and purchase options across 40+ countries.
United States
USStream
2Available in 131 countries
Frequently asked about My Fault
Common questions people search for, with answers written by us at MoviesPack.
Will there be part 2 of Your Fault?
Yes. Your Fault (Culpa tuya), the second installment in the Culpables trilogy, was released on Prime Video on 27 December 2024.
Is there part 3 of My Fault, Culpa mía?
Our Fault (Culpa nuestra) is the third and final film in the trilogy, with Prime Video confirming a 2025 release to close out the story adapted from Mercedes Ron's novels.
What is the order of the My Fault movies?
The trilogy follows the order of the source novels: My Fault (Culpa mía, 2023), Your Fault (Culpa tuya, 2024), and Our Fault (Culpa nuestra, 2025).
Is My Fault worth watching?
Reception is mixed, with a TMDB user score of 6.1 reflecting strong appeal for fans of forbidden-romance YA dramas but weaker reviews from critics who flagged the predictable plot and stepsibling premise.
Why does Noah move into William Leister's mansion at the start of the film?
Noah's mother Rafaela begins a relationship with billionaire William Leister and the two quickly get engaged, prompting Noah and her mother to leave their modest home and move into William's sprawling mansion. Noah is deeply uncomfortable with the sudden wealth and the upheaval to her life, which sets up the tension and culture-clash dynamic that drives the early story.
Why do Noah and Nick initially clash so aggressively with each other?
Nick is William's son and resents the intrusion of Noah and her mother into his privileged world, while Noah refuses to be intimidated by his arrogance and wealth. Their hostility is also fueled by a mutual attraction they both try to suppress, causing them to lash out rather than acknowledge their feelings. The antagonism is a defense mechanism on both sides before their relationship slowly shifts toward romance.
What is the significance of Nick's underground street racing and how does it put Noah in danger?
Nick participates in illegal street races, a reckless habit that reflects his need for adrenaline and his rebellion against his controlled, wealthy upbringing. Noah discovers this secret and becomes entangled in his dangerous world, eventually placing herself in a threatening situation when she follows him to one of the races. The racing subplot is used to raise the stakes of their relationship and force Nick to confront the consequences his lifestyle has for people he cares about.
Why does Nick keep pulling away from Noah even after they grow close?
Nick is aware that pursuing Noah is complicated by the fact that their parents are engaged, which would effectively make them stepsiblings in the eyes of their blended family. He is also guarded due to past emotional wounds and fears that a real relationship with Noah could disrupt the family dynamic and hurt people around them. His repeated withdrawal is driven by guilt and a sense of responsibility, not a lack of genuine feeling for her.
How does the film end and do Noah and Nick end up together?
By the end of the film, Noah and Nick acknowledge their feelings and choose to be together despite the complications posed by their parents' relationship. The movie closes on an optimistic note for their romance but deliberately leaves their future unresolved, setting up the sequel "My Fault: London" (also based on Mercedes Ron's trilogy). The ending prioritizes the emotional payoff of the central love story while acknowledging that the obstacles between them have not fully disappeared.
Recent Updates
New Trailer: My Fault
My Fault now streaming on Amazon Prime Video with Ads (FR)
My Fault now streaming on Amazon Prime Video (FR)
My Fault now streaming on Amazon Prime Video with Ads (DE)
My Fault now streaming on Amazon Prime Video (DE)