Movies Like I'm in Love with a Church Girl

Ranked by shared directors, cast, themes, genre, and era — not just generic recommendations.

Gabriel's Inferno: Part II

2020·1h 46m·★ 6.3·Tosca Musk

Fans also likedRomance & Drama

Life in a Year

2020·1h 47m·★ 6.3·Mitja Okorn

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

Love Everlasting

2016·1h 32m·★ 6.3·Rob Diamond

Fans also likedRomance & Drama

My Fault: London

2025·1h 59m·★ 6.2·Dani Girdwood

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

The Secret: Dare to Dream

2020·1h 47m·★ 6.6·Andy Tennant

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

An Autumn Romance

2021·1h 28m·★ 5.6·Bradley Walsh

Fans also likedRomance & Drama

The Fugitive Kind

1960·1h 59m·★ 7.0·Sidney Lumet

Fans also likedRomance & Drama

Ali and Nino

2016·1h 40m·★ 6.8·Asif Kapadia

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

Two for the Seesaw

1962·1h 59m·★ 6.6·Robert Wise

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

Not Easily Broken

2009·1h 39m·★ 6.1·Bill Duke

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

We

2019·1h 26m·★ 5.6·Mani Nasry

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

Fire with Fire

1986·1h 43m·★ 6.4·Duncan Gibbins

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

Blind

2017·1h 45m·★ 5.8·Michael Mailer

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

Dirt Music

2020·1h 45m·★ 5.4·Gregor Jordan

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

Hello, Goodbye, and Everything in Between

2022·1h 23m·★ 5.2·Michael Lewen

Fans also likedRomance & Drama

Nine Lives

2005·1h 55m·★ 6.7·Rodrigo García

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

Wander Darkly

2020·1h 37m·★ 5.8·Tara Miele

Fans also likedRomance & Drama

The Golden Bowl

2000·2h 10m·★ 5.9·James Ivory

Fans also likedRomance & Drama

Maria's Lovers

1984·1h 49m·★ 6.5·Andrei Konchalovsky

Fans also likedDrama & Romance

The Cookout

2004·1h 37m·★ 3.9·Lance Rivera

Both star Ja Rule & Vincent Pastore

How Good Is I'm in Love with a Church Girl?

Ratings across IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB, plus our verdict.