Movies Like Butter

Ranked by shared directors, cast, themes, genre, and era — not just generic recommendations.

She's Out of My League

2010·1h 44m·★ 6.4·Jim Field Smith

2 shared crewDir. Jim Field SmithDP: Jim Denault

Cedar Rapids

2011·1h 27m·★ 6.3·Miguel Arteta

TMDB recommendsStarring Rob Corddry

The Straight Story

1999·1h 52m·★ 8.0·David Lynch

TMDB recommends

The Bridges of Madison County

1995·2h 15m·★ 7.6·Clint Eastwood

TMDB recommends

What's Eating Gilbert Grape

1993·1h 58m·★ 7.7·Lasse Hallström

TMDB recommends

Deadpool & Wolverine

2024·2h 8m·★ 7.5·Shawn Levy

Both star Hugh Jackman & Jennifer Garner

Field of Dreams

1989·1h 45m·★ 7.5·Phil Alden Robinson

TMDB recommends

The Music Man

1962·2h 31m·★ 7.7·Morton DaCosta

TMDB recommends

Sleeping with the Enemy

1991·1h 39m·★ 6.3·Joseph Ruben

TMDB recommends

King Corn

2007·1h 28m·★ 7.0·Aaron Woolf

TMDB recommends

The Pajama Game

1957·1h 43m·★ 6.6·George Abbott

TMDB recommends

Cold Turkey

1971·1h 39m·★ 6.6·Norman Lear

TMDB recommends

State Fair

1933·1h 37m·★ 6.6·Henry King

TMDB recommends

The Puppet Masters

1994·1h 49m·★ 5.9·Stuart Orme

TMDB recommends

The Tribes of Palos Verdes

2017·1h 44m·★ 5.9·Brendan Malloy

Both star Jennifer Garner & Alicia Silverstone

How Good Is Butter?

Ratings across IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB, plus our verdict.