

Similar Films
Movies Like Amish Witches: The True Story of Holmes County
2016·87 min·Dir. Jake Wade Wall·★ 4.4
HorrorTV Movie
A television reality crew has arrived in town to document facts about an isolated Amish sect. Filming is interrupted when the grandmother of their host family, a shunned witch, dies and is denied a Christian burial. When paranormal activities begin to plague the family, they ask the crew to document it. But they never foresee the dangers that the spirits have in store for them.
Ranked by shared directors, cast, themes, genre, and era — not just generic recommendations.

King Kong
1933·1h 44m·★ 7.9·Merian C. Cooper
TMDB recommends

Ghostwatch
1992·1h 31m·★ 7.3·Lesley Manning
Fans also likedHorror & TV Movie

The Woman in Black
1989·1h 40m·★ 7.0·Herbert Wise
Fans also likedHorror & TV Movie

The Blackwell Ghost 3
2019·1h 15m·★ 6.2·Turner Clay
TMDB recommends

Primate
2026·1h 29m·★ 5.8·Johannes Roberts
TMDB recommends

The Blair Witch Project
1999·1h 21m·★ 6.5·Daniel Myrick
TMDB recommends

Dreams in the Witch House
2005·55m·★ 6.5·Stuart Gordon
Fans also likedHorror & TV Movie

D@bbe: The Possession
2013·2h 14m·★ 6.7·Hasan Karacadağ
TMDB recommends

Mr. Boogedy
1986·44m·★ 6.5·Oz Scott
Fans also likedTV Movie & Horror

American Horror House
2012·1h 25m·★ 3.8·Darin Scott
Fans also likedHorror & TV Movie

The Haunted
1991·1h 40m·★ 6.2·Robert Mandel
Fans also likedHorror & TV Movie

The Legend of Boggy Creek
1972·1h 27m·★ 5.3·Charles B. Pierce
TMDB recommends

Bad Ben 5: The Crescent Moon Clown
2018·1h 27m·★ 3.2·Nigel Bach
TMDB recommends

Capture Kill Release
2016·1h 36m·★ 5.3·Nick McAnulty
TMDB recommends

Cursed
2023·3m·Mohamed El Husseini
TMDB recommends
How Good Is Amish Witches: The True Story of Holmes County?
Ratings across IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB, plus our verdict.
Consensus
4.5Poorly Received
Score Breakdown
★ TMDB4.5
★ IMDb4.4
🍅 Rotten Tomatoes (Critics)N/A
◆ MetacriticN/A
The Verdict
Probably Skip This One
Related Collections
Find More