Shows Like One of Us Is Lying

Ranked by shared creators, cast, themes, genre, and network — not just generic recommendations.

Heartstopper

2022·S3 · 24 episodes·★ 8.5

4 shared themes: sapphic, lgbt teen, teen drama...Fans also watched

Love, Victor

2020·S3 · 28 episodes·★ 7.9

Themes: sapphic, lgbt teen, lgbtFans also watched

Riverdale

2017·S7 · 137 episodes·★ 6.4

Themes: murder mystery, teen drama, lgbtFans also watchedDrama & Mystery

School Spirits

2023·S3 · 24 episodes·★ 7.6

Themes: lgbt teen, lgbtFans also watchedMystery & Drama

Pretty Little Liars

2010·S7 · 161 episodes·★ 7.3

Fans also watchedThemes: based on young adult novel, teen dramaDrama & Mystery

Only Murders in the Building

2021·S5 · 50 episodes·★ 8.0

Fans also watchedThemes: murder mystery, lgbt

Veronica Mars

2004·S4 · 72 episodes·★ 8.3

Fans also watchedMystery & Drama

The Crowded Room

2023·S1 · 10 episodes·★ 7.7

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

Tell Me Lies

2022·S3 · 26 episodes·★ 7.2

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

The Girlfriend

2025·S1 · 6 episodes·★ 7.1

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

Scream: The TV Series

2015·S3 · 29 episodes·★ 7.0

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin

2022·S2 · 18 episodes·★ 7.0

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

Why Didn't They Ask Evans?

2022·S1 · 3 episodes·★ 7.0

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

Nancy Drew

2019·S4 · 62 episodes·★ 6.8

Fans also watchedMystery & Drama

A Good Girl's Guide to Murder

2024·S2 · 12 episodes·★ 6.8

Themes: based on young adult novel, murder mysteryMystery & Drama

The Order

2019·S2 · 20 episodes·★ 6.7

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

Harlan Coben's Shelter

2023·S1 · 8 episodes·★ 6.6

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

The Survivors

2025·S1 · 6 episodes·★ 6.6

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

Playing Gracie Darling

2025·S1 · 6 episodes·★ 6.2

Fans also watchedDrama & Mystery

Gossip Girl

2007·S6 · 121 episodes·★ 7.5

Themes: based on young adult novel, teen dramaDrama & Mystery

How Good Is One of Us Is Lying?

Ratings across IMDb and TMDB, plus our verdict.

Where to Watch One of Us Is Lying

Streaming, rental, and purchase options across 40+ countries.

CountryUnited States

Type

AllStreamRentBuyTheaters

United States

US

Stream

2

Peacock Premium

Peacock Premium Plus

Buy

3

Amazon Video

Apple TV Store

Fandango At Home

Available in 10 countries